Objections

OBJECTIONS: Trans-Existential Grounding, answered; Geir Isene <https://isene.com/freewill/>
How to read this
Each objection is stated the way a critic would put it, then answered
The answers come from the three papers and from correspondence
Search finds any objection; click a line to fold or unfold it
The three conditions on any cause of existence
OUTSIDE: anything inside existence is part of what needs the cause
PROPERTY-FREE: a property asks "why this one?" and puts its bearer back inside E
SUSTAINING: the order is caused at every instant, not once at the beginning
Objections to the requirement (Paper 1: Why Existence Cannot Ground Itself)
OBJECTION: Some facts just are
That is the brute fact, and the premise refuses it: whatever is one way and not another must have an account
A brute fact still has features, and each asks "why this way and not another?"
Science refuses that stop everywhere else; keeping it for the biggest question is a dogmatic choice
The cause escapes the premise: it is no way at all, so the question runs out by itself
OBJECTION: The definition rigs the game
The definition only says what counts as existing
That a cause is needed comes from the premise and the six steps
OBJECTION: An endless chain needs no first ground
Each link has its account in the next; the chain as a whole has none
Leibniz: a geometry book copied from an older copy, forever back; why there are such books at all is not explained
Taken whole, an endless chain just is: a brute fact; a loop is the same
OBJECTION: Explain each link, and the chain is explained
Hume made this move with twenty particles, Edwards with five people on a street corner
It works when each member has an account from outside the group
It fails for the books, where links only explain links
OBJECTION: Laws are descriptions, not prescriptions
On a Humean reading laws sum up regularities; nothing formal governs anything
The regularities are all the argument needs
The pattern is exact, and it is there where nobody is describing anything
Why the behaviour has that order is still the question
OBJECTION: The numbers make arithmetic consistent, and need do nothing
That the numbers form one consistent whole needs a proof, and the proof runs in a stronger system
Without a proof, "the numbers just exist" is a brute fact
And a structure does not settle which laws are realised
OBJECTION: Something with no properties is nothing
The cause does work: it causes; nothing causes nothing
If it were nothing, existence would have no account, which is the brute fact the premise refuses
"Causes" names the role it plays, not a feature it has
Potential is the better word, and sheer nothing has no potential
OBJECTION: A necessary being ends the chain
Right about one thing: the chain must end in something that could not be otherwise
Then it gives that end a character, all-knowing and all-good, and the questions start again
Gödel's ontological proof lands here too: its being has every positive property, so it is inside E
A computer has checked Dana Scott's version: its axioms agree, and they make every true fact necessary
OBJECTION: Then everything is necessary
Van Inwagen: the account of all facts together is necessary, and if it forces the rest, nothing could have gone otherwise
A world that is necessarily so, with no account, is the brute fact in its largest form
And the cause cannot force: forcing needs a rule, and a rule is a property
OBJECTION: Consciousness emerges from the brain, so nothing needs grounding
Emergence starts from parts, relations and laws, which is what needs the cause
No matter how complex a system gets, it cannot leave its own category
No arrangement of Lego makes a four-dimensional object
W and E are disjoint, so this is not a claim about pushing atoms around
OBJECTION: Anything beyond materialism is religion in disguise
The cause is given no character, no attributes and no intentions toward anyone
A deity with attributes is turned down in the same paper, on the same grounds
Multiverse and many-worlds are more existence, so they inherit the problem
OBJECTION: The argument sits inside existence too
It never claims to prove itself
What it does from inside is fix the cause by what the cause cannot be
The limit is real: from inside, what the cause IS cannot be settled
Objections to the identification (Paper 2: The Ground Must Choose)
OBJECTION: Undetermined means lucky, not free
The standard objection to libertarian accounts, and a good one
It has force against accounts that put choice inside physics, where undetermined means chance
W is not a process in the brain; it is the ground of the process
The determined-or-lucky pair is exactly what the theorem denies
Levy's stronger form: nothing about the chooser explains why this and not that
Reply from step 8: luck at every instant is causing that keeps nothing, and such causing drifts
What is caused is kept, and order lasts; choice differs from luck by keeping what it made
OBJECTION: You have renamed the mystery
A property-free cause that acts by no rule explains nothing, it just labels the gap
A version of this is accepted: the framework cannot say HOW the causing works
A how would be a rule, and rules were excluded
What it does instead: derive the conditions, then show the familiar candidates failing them
Call it unbound causing that keeps what it made, and nothing changes
Less than an explanation, more than a name
OBJECTION: The premise rules out choice
The premise asks for an account, and an account is whatever a fact comes from
Coming from something is not being forced by it; a chosen fact comes from the chooser
"Why this choice?" asks for a feature of the ground that tipped it, and it has none
Nor can the chooser compel the choice: compelling takes a rule, and rules are properties
Choice is the one account that compels nothing, and only such an account can end a chain of accounts
Pruss defends the premise against van Inwagen's argument and leaves room for free choice
OBJECTION: Physics is causally closed
Closure is a working rule of physics of great value, not a measurement
The causing adds no energy and breaks no conservation law
Where physics leaves an outcome open, making one definite intervenes on nothing
OBJECTION: How can something property-free move something physical?
The question pictures a world standing ready and a ground reaching in to nudge it
There is no standing world: E is what the causing yields, at every moment
Continuous creation, not interaction
How the property-free creates has no answer of the usual kind, since an answer would be a rule
OBJECTION: Random causing would create existence just as well
Existence is caused at every moment, and chance gives no reason why one moment's order is the next moment's
Patterns persist: a cup stays a cup, and F=ma held yesterday
Chance also needs a spread of odds, and any limit on that spread is a rule again
OBJECTION: Chance within limits gives stable order
It does, and that gives the point away: the limits are doing the work
Limits are rules, and step 7 excluded them
OBJECTION: Everything is already determined, so nothing is left to make definite
A fixed future needs every state given to infinite precision, and no physical state has that
Weather, turbulence and warm, wet matter magnify the missing detail
Bell tests: nature does not carry its answers around in advance
OBJECTION: Every possibility happens, in many worlds
Then nothing becomes definite, since every outcome happens on some branch
That is more existence with no account of it, like the multiverse
It leaves out the one fact every observer has: experience runs down a single branch
OBJECTION: There is a fourth way to cause
Show one and the identification falls
The three cases come from splitting one question twice, so no fourth can be added
Something inside binds the causing, or nothing does; if nothing does, what was made carries over, or nothing does
OBJECTION: Then a computer could choose too
A machine runs a procedure: the same input and state give the same output
Adding a random source changes the spread of outputs, not their kind
One is rule and the other is odds, and step 7 excluded both
No claim against ability: a machine may match us at any task we can specify
Objections to the individual (Paper 3: What Is Aware Is the Ground)
OBJECTION: There is no observer, only the brain's model of one
A model has properties, so it is inside E, and things inside E start nothing
A model also has to appear to someone, and that someone is what the paper is about
You know that there is awareness, by being it; no argument from outside can show that to someone who denies it
OBJECTION: Brain scans observe awareness
A scan shows blood flow, electric rhythms and busy parts: all properties, all inside E
It shows what awareness is aware through: a body, senses and memory
No scan shows awareness itself; the researcher reads the picture by being aware
OBJECTION: Anaesthesia switches the observer off
The drug changes the brain; content stops, and so does the recording of it
A gap in memory is missing content, and it does not show that nobody was there
What is aware has no content of its own to lose
OBJECTION: "Aware" is itself a property
A property marks a thing off from another: this charge, that mass
"Aware" says what role this plays, and gives it no character
OBJECTION: Then there is only one of us
The choosing is not many; the individuals are
We differ because our kept commitments differ, and those are properties
The choosing has none, so nothing marks one choosing off from another
Being aware of this line rather than that one is no feature of what is aware; the difference sits in the lines
The objection pictures the choosing as a bigger person that swallows the rest of us; it is no person at all
OBJECTION: Split-brain and multiple personality: which observer?
The surgeries and the dissociations divide content: two fields of report, two sets of memories
Content is what is observed, never the observer
The choosing was never one per body, so no number of observers has to be reassigned
OBJECTION: A newborn, an animal, a machine: who is aware?
In none of them does a brain or a circuit choose; a procedure and its odds are both properties
If anything is aware in any of them, it is the ground
Which lines of commitments the ground is aware of cannot be settled from outside
The output of an AI may be as good as any person's; output is content, and shows nothing about what is aware
OBJECTION: This is the old teaching in new words
Accepted: the Upanishads and Shankara reach the not-two by practice and report
This paper reaches it from two premises and an exclusion, and asks for its premises to be attacked
OBJECTION: Then the individual survives the death of the body
Nothing here decides it; that question belongs to a separate paper
Side road: Gödel, against the final theory
Nothing in the six steps depends on this section
It closes one escape: the hope of a theory that accounts for itself
OBJECTION: Gödel does not apply outside mathematics
Franzén catalogued the misuse and warned against stretching incompleteness to all of reality
The warning is deserved; most such arguments equivocate on "system"
This section needs only that formal systems exist inside E and cannot vouch for themselves
That is Gödel used on the objects it was proved about: the laws, written out
Nothing needs existence as a whole to be a formal system
OBJECTION: Existence is no system; it only contains systems
Then something with no formal character keeps producing formal character, at every scale
That production asks for an account; the problem is renamed, not removed
OBJECTION: Consistency is an artefact of observation
We may perceive consistency because inconsistent regions are unobservable
Grant it: an inconsistent existence supporting stable observers is the more puzzling one
The stability still needs an account
OBJECTION: Existence is not consistent
A real way out of this section: the theorem says nothing about systems that contradict themselves
The price is high: a contradictory existence has no reason to show the stable order we measure
The six steps are untouched either way
OBJECTION: Physics may need only the safe parts of mathematics
Some parts of mathematics are complete, and the theorems leave them alone
Physics does not live there: the wave equation, the tiling problem and the spectral gap are undecidable
Mathematics that rich contains arithmetic, and arithmetic is all the theorem needs
OBJECTION: Category theory escapes to a higher level
Lawvere proved Cantor, Gödel and Tarski are one categorical pattern (1969)
Climbing to a richer theory carries the limit along
Either it is formal, and the theorem applies, or it produces formal structure that needs its own account
OBJECTION: This only shows we have not found all the laws yet
The incompleteness is structural, not a gap in our knowledge
No complete set of laws inside existence can establish its own consistency
OBJECTION: The argument undermines itself
It is a formal argument inside E, so does its own conclusion defeat it?
It never claims to prove its own consistency
It claims that a consistent system of the relevant kind cannot prove its consistency from inside
Objections to scope and method
OBJECTION: The argument assumes free will, then proves it
The order runs the other way
The requirement comes first, from one premise; the conditions on the cause follow from it
Only then is the question asked which candidate meets them
If another candidate is found then something new is learned
What would defeat the argument (from the papers)
Deny the premise: say "it just is"
The widest point; every step opens
The price: it is the one dogmatic answer we accept nowhere else in inquiry
Show that something inside the ground can bind the causing without being a feature of it
Show that order does not last
Exhibit a cause inside E that meets <The three conditions on any cause of existence>
Produce a property that could not in principle enter any view
Find the observer in a view without turning it into content
Tell two awarenesses apart without introducing properties
Where to read the arguments in full
The three papers and the framework map <https://isene.com/freewill/>
#TEG #freewill #objections #choice
Graphhypergraph of this HyperList