TEG

TEG: The Trans-Existential Grounding framework; Geir Isene <https://isene.com/freewill/>
The framework in one line
Existence needs a cause outside itself, and that cause must choose
The three parts are not held with equal confidence, by design
The requirement is PROVED, if the premise is granted <Paper 1: Why Existence Cannot Ground Itself>
The identification is ARGUED, by elimination <Paper 2: The Ground Must Choose>
The individual is ARGUED in the first person <Paper 3: What Is Aware Is the Ground>
Paper 1: Why Existence Cannot Ground Itself
CLAIM: Existence cannot account for itself; its cause lies outside it and has no properties
Definition: Existence (E) = everything that has properties
Rocks and the laws they obey; thoughts, numbers, proofs
A property is any feature that marks a thing off from another: seven from eight
The definition runs both ways: to exist is to have properties, and to have properties is to exist
That something exists is taken as given
Having no features at all is not one more feature
The premise: whatever is one way and not another must have an account
There are no brute facts
The premise covers a whole as much as its parts; the account of a whole is none of its own parts
Fair: a brute fact still has features, and each asks "why this way and not another?"
Science refuses that stop everywhere else; keeping it for the biggest question is a dogmatic choice
The cause escapes it: it is no way at all, so the question runs out by itself
Steps 1 to 6: the requirement
1 Whatever is one way and not another must have an account (the premise)
2 Existence is everything with properties, and everything with properties exists
3 Properties need a cause that has no properties
Any cause with properties needs its own cause: diamond, lattice, forces, constants
A chain of causes with no end is a brute fact taken whole; so is a loop
Leibniz's picture: a geometry book copied from an older copy, with no first copy
Three endings: no properties; runs forever (a brute fact); stops for no reason (a brute fact)
4 That cause is one; two would have to differ, and a difference is a property (Pure Potential)
5 A place in time is a property, so Pure Potential has no place in time
6 So Pure Potential causes everything that exists, at every instant
Not one act in the past: it is here now, and existence would cease without it
Three conditions on any such cause
OUTSIDE existence: anything inside is part of what needs the cause (step 3)
NO properties: a property asks "why this one?" and puts its bearer back inside (step 3)
SUSTAINS order: to sustain is to cause at every instant (step 6)
Every candidate fails
A god with attributes; each attribute is one way and not another
Numbers and forms; their consistency needs a proof in a stronger system, or is a brute fact
Tegmark's mathematical universe; mathematics has properties, so it is inside E
The quantum vacuum; fields with energy and symmetries; calling that state "nothing" is word play
The multiverse; a rule for which worlds happen is a property
Emergence; it starts from parts, relations and laws, exactly what needs the cause
A necessary being; right that the chain ends, wrong to give the end a character
Gödel's ontological proof lands here too: its being has every positive property
A computer checked Dana Scott's version: its axioms agree, and they make every true fact necessary
Every candidate is inside E, or carries features that put it inside
Side road: Gödel, against the final theory
Nothing in the six steps depends on this section
The objection: physics will reach a final theory, and that theory will account for itself
Written out, a final theory is a formal system with arithmetic inside it
Gödel 1931: no consistent system with arithmetic can establish its own consistency
A stronger system can do it for a weaker one, and then its own is open; the ladder never ends
Machine form: no system shows that its own contradiction-hunt never ends (Turing)
Used on formal systems inside E; nothing needs E as a whole to be one
[? existence is no system, only contains systems] something formless keeps producing exact form, and that asks for an account
Where to push
Attack the premise: say "it just is", and every step opens
What survives: a requirement, not a name; how Pure Potential causes is the next question <Paper 2: The Ground Must Choose>
Paper 2: The Ground Must Choose (free will as trans-existential ground)
CLAIM: Of the three ways Pure Potential could cause, only choice meets the conditions
The question: how does Pure Potential cause existence?
To cause, here, is to create what is actual
Split the question twice: something inside binds the causing, or nothing does
If nothing binds it: what it made carries over, or nothing does
Three cases, and the two splits leave no room for a fourth
Steps 7 to 9: the identification
7 Nothing in Pure Potential binds the causing
A rule is a property of whatever follows it
Odds over a set of outcomes are structure, and structure has properties
"Random within limits" concedes the point: limits are rules
A purpose, a nature, a leaning one way: each is a feature of whatever carries it
A rule-run cause is a formal system <Side road: Gödel, against the final theory>
8 The causing keeps what it made
Then nothing would account for the lasting order we observe: the fine structure constant is steady across billions of years
A selection effect explains why we see order, never why anything ordered is there to see
Without keeping, the third condition fails
9 What is left is choice
Causing that nothing forces and nothing randomises
To keep is what one does with a promise; nothing is stored, each moment is caused anew
Keeping is no feature of the ground: it is chosen again at every instant
Strip deliberation, reasons and awareness: all three are structures inside E
THEOREM: How Pure Potential causes
[? the three conditions hold] nothing inside Pure Potential binds its causing, and the causing keeps what it made
The determined-or-lucky pair was never the whole list
Open: whether "choice" is the right word; the elimination stands either way
The framework
P = Pure Potential, what has no properties; W = the same thing, named by what it does: decide
W and E are disjoint by construction (W ∩ E = ∅)
Actualisation maps a decision and a moment to an actualised state of affairs
Continuous: starting existence and sustaining it are one operation
On no rule, so no computation carries it out
E is the IMAGE of actualisation: no arena beforehand, no furniture to rearrange
Existence comes from free will; free will does not come from existence
COROLLARY: body, brain, memory and character have properties, so they start nothing
Either there is no free will, or the choosing is the ground's own <Paper 3: What Is Aware Is the Ground>
Remark: the empty set has no members, yet the whole cumulative hierarchy builds from it
Indeterminacy is real
Classical: no physical state is fixed to infinite precision (Potter, Ellis and Mitchell)
Chaos and turbulence make that indefiniteness large
Quantum: Bell violations, loophole-free; local hidden variables excluded
Bohm needs positions of infinite precision; Many-Worlds makes nothing definite at all
Superdeterminism is the brute fact in local dress
It shows the outcome was open; it does not show that free will makes it definite
Constraint from one's own choices
Each act of causing makes something definite, and what is definite must be kept up
Volitional entropy: the pile of kept choices, felt as constraint
The chess analogy: the rules arrived with the decision to play (laws of physics as standing commitments)
A chooser of long standing SHOULD feel as bound as we do
Computation cannot choose
A machine runs a procedure; adding a random source is odds; step 7 excludes both
No claim against capability: behaviour is a poor guide to the presence of W
Responsibility
Structural, not adopted: the chooser made it actual, so the chooser owns it
Related work: indeterminism without a ground
Potter, Ellis and Mitchell: the free will debate assumes determinism, and physics does not support it
Agreed: the future stands open; their classical case is taken over here
Potter and Mitchell answer five forms of the luck objection for the organism
They deny fixed odds behind a choice, and name nothing that makes the open future definite
Their agency works inside the order and starts nothing; their argument begins where this one ends
What this does not establish
Neither paper sees the ground; both stand or fall on what they rule out
That human beings are W: argued in the first person <Paper 3: What Is Aware Is the Ground>
Paper 3: What Is Aware Is the Ground
CLAIM: what is aware in you has no properties, so it is not two with the ground
The premise of observation: whatever has properties could, in principle, show up for someone
Directly or indirectly; indirectly counts only when what arrives shows a feature of its source
It follows from keeping (step 9): to be fitted, what was made must reach the causing
It is about properties; verificationism was a rule about sentences
The observer is never observed
Everything you can point to as "me" has properties: body, thoughts, memories, character
Whatever you observe is one more thing you are aware of, never the awareness
A mirror shows the eye an image, and the image is one more thing seen
Introspection finds content; in others you see a face, words, a smile, never what is aware behind them
You know that there is awareness, by being it; you never find out what it is like
So what is aware has no properties
Not two: two would differ by a property, and neither has one (step 4 applied to the observer)
Say "not two", never "one": counting begins where things can be told apart
"Aware" names a role, as "causes" does in paper 1
The individual
An individual is a line of kept commitments, with the ground aware of it
The lines differ, so the individuals are many; the choosing behind them is not two
Being aware of this line rather than that one is no feature of what is aware; the difference sits in the lines
A feeling sits on one line, and no line contains another's feelings
The laws are kept commitments wider than any individual; one line does not command the rest
What this does not establish
Whether a line of commitments survives the death of its body: a separate paper
Which matter is open to fresh choosing, how commitments are kept, whether awareness comes in degrees
Where to push
Produce a property that could not in principle enter any view
Find the observer in a view without turning it into content
Tell two awarenesses apart without introducing properties
Marked as argued from the first person, never proved from inside E
Reading the three
Take the requirement (proved) even if you decline the identification (argued)
[? the second paper does not convince] you have taken what was established and declined what was proposed
#TEG #freewill #grounding #choice
Graphhypergraph of this HyperList