Existence cannot account for itself. Whatever causes it cannot be one more thing inside it, and nothing inside it binds the causing. What is left is choice.
"Transcendence of Choice"
W ∩ E = ∅. The ground is not a part of what it causes, and existence is what its choosing yields, moment by moment.
Everything that exists has properties. Properties need a cause that has no properties. That cause can only be choice.
A property is a feature that sets one thing apart from another.A placement in space or time is a property.
Whatever has properties, one thing or all things together, requires an account from outside it.A property does not cause itself.
Existence is the collection of all things with a property.
Existence needs an account from outside existence, at all placements in time.
We call that account Pure Potential. It has no properties.A rule inside it would be a property, so no rule commands it.
To account for the order we see, Pure Potential must commit to what it made.Causing that has no rules, and that commits, is choice: Free Will.
Commitments limit choice. They limit the freedom of will.
Every other cause has been tried: a god with attributes, numbers, the quantum vacuum, the multiverse. Each one has properties, so each one needs a cause too.
And you? What is aware in you is never seen, so it has no properties. It is not two with Pure Potential.
Each proof as a funnel: premises in, conclusions out. Tap to play the video (2:42), or open the picture.
Eleven steps. Agree or object at each one, and see where you stand at the end.
Walk through the argumentA computation runs a procedure, and adding a random source only changes the spread of its output. Neither is choice, at any scale or architecture.
If your choices bring states of affairs into being, you stand in a relation to them. No account of your causal history dissolves it.
Every choice held in force is a commitment, and commitments constrain further choosing. A long-standing chooser should feel exactly as bound as we do.
Three papers carry the argument. Everything else here is a way into them.
The requirement. Whatever is one way and not another must have an account. The argument ends at a cause outside existence with no properties, and every candidate inside fails.
PDF · 6 pages · note on Gödel (3 pages)
Every premise and conclusion of the three papers, in logic and in plain words.
PDF · 1 page · checked by Lean (A3) · infographic · from free will to the ground (3 pages)