W ∩ E = ∅

The Trans-Existential Grounding Framework (TEG)

Existence cannot account for itself. Whatever causes it cannot be one more thing inside it, and nothing inside it binds the causing. What is left is choice.

Transcendence of Choice - a painting of form emerging out of formlessness

"Transcendence of Choice"
W ∩ E = ∅. The ground is not a part of what it causes, and existence is what its choosing yields, moment by moment.

The argument

Everything that exists has properties. Properties need a cause that has no properties. That cause can only be choice.

The argument in short

A property is a feature that sets one thing apart from another.A placement in space or time is a property.

Whatever has properties, one thing or all things together, requires an account from outside it.A property does not cause itself.

Existence is the collection of all things with a property.

Existence needs an account from outside existence, at all placements in time.

We call that account Pure Potential. It has no properties.A rule inside it would be a property, so no rule commands it.

To account for the order we see, Pure Potential must commit to what it made.Causing that has no rules, and that commits, is choice: Free Will.

Commitments limit choice. They limit the freedom of will.

Every other cause has been tried: a god with attributes, numbers, the quantum vacuum, the multiverse. Each one has properties, so each one needs a cause too.

And you? What is aware in you is never seen, so it has no properties. It is not two with Pure Potential.

Four funnels. In each, the premises of one proof fall in as balls, and its conclusions come out below.

Each proof as a funnel: premises in, conclusions out. Tap to play the video (2:42), or open the picture.

Eleven steps. Agree or object at each one, and see where you stand at the end.

Walk through the argument

What follows

No machine chooses

A computation runs a procedure, and adding a random source only changes the spread of its output. Neither is choice, at any scale or architecture.

Responsibility is structural

If your choices bring states of affairs into being, you stand in a relation to them. No account of your causal history dissolves it.

Freedom accumulates weight

Every choice held in force is a commitment, and commitments constrain further choosing. A long-standing chooser should feel exactly as bound as we do.

Geir Isene

Geir Isene

I work on the grounding of existence and on free will. The papers below are the current statement of that work, and the book behind them is in progress. I have spent decades coaching people through hard decisions, which is where the questions started.

Visit isene.org

Access the Complete Work

Three papers carry the argument. Everything else here is a way into them.

Stay Updated

Get notified about responses to this work, speaking engagements, and new developments